Director's Cut

Jo Pyar Dar Jaaye, Who Pyar Pyar Nahi,
Jurm Hai, Aiyyashi Hai.

(the love that gets scared is not love, it's a sin, it's indulgence)


S is an Indian friend of mine who claims to have fallen in love with a Chinese girl Q. They meet everyday and spend the evenings together. I haven't seen him so happy in a very long time. If he doesn't meet Q one day, he becomes strangely quite and asocial. It would seem he has got addicted to the company of Q.

I have met Q several times, and the two really seem to be in love. They share an amazing chemistry between them. Both bring out the other one's free child in a very high degree, and as a good friend of both of them, I have had the good fortune of watching the beautiful phenomenon blooming almost in front of my eyes.

But...God, the greatest sadists of all, makes sure that every beautiful package has an ugly edge, so ugly that it's hard to overlook it and for most people, it’s a sufficient reason not to carry the package along in their lives and leave it behind in beautifully decorated garbage bins labeled as "sweet memory".

The ugly edge in the package of love between S and Q was C—the Chinese boy friend of Q. She had been dating him for a year when S and Q met. Now why Q gave herself the permission to fall for S in the first place can be an interesting study in itself, and will be very relevant to the discussion here; but unfortunately I don't have much of insight into the thought processes of Q. In any case, we will be making certain basic assumptions regarding the feelings between S and Q during this discussion that renders the initial feelings of Q towards S irrelevant to this document.

One day I noticed some turbulence in the usually jovial state of S. He explained later that C has discovered about Q dating him, and Q is in a terrible state due to the pangs of her conscious. Q was of the opinion that she should stop seeing S anymore.

I suggested S to look for some opportune moment and ask her certain questions. Part of the dialogue went something like this:

S: Tell me the truth, not what I want to hear. What do you feel when you kiss me? Do you ever think of C?
(Now normally no girl should be telling the truth for such a question, but my personal understanding of human nature makes me believe that under the given situation, she wouldn't lie to S. A person under such a situation wishes someone else to take the decision for him, and hence would tell the truth, especially if it's an ugly one!!!)

Q: I feel good, but I don't think of C.

S: How do you feel when you kiss C? Do you ever think of me at those times?

Q: (with certain uneasiness that S was able to notice) I think of you sometimes and I don't feel good at such times.

S: Do you sleep with him?

Q: No.
(Something in the way she said it, S claims, made him doubt the truthfulness of such a statement. Now against the light of my previous statement, this observation might seem contradictory in the first place, but, then again there are degrees of everything. Sleeping with someone is a much more profound way of the belongingness is expressed; it was, as compared to kissing, much more embarrassing for Q and, probably in her opinion, much more hurting to S. So it’s possible that she might have decided to curtail the truth here.)

If we were to believe the truth of Q's claims (which I would like to for the sake of argument here), Q had developed strong feelings for S over the period they have dated.

The focus of my interest now goes to the feelings of S and I wanted to validate his claims of love. I poked him for further details. I knew I wouldn't have to try too hard, because I could clearly see a glint of righteousness in his eyes. Any person who thinks he has done the right thing is more than eager in his heart to talk about it to someone he looks up to or to someone who looks up to him. The positive stroke during the process is too hard for most people to resist.

So S went on to tell me how he managed to lift Q from her sad state. He was able to convince Q to keep seeing him until he returns to his country[1]. He suggested keeping seeing each other strictly as friends (they would refrain from any sexual activities) as long as Q wasn't sure what she wanted to do[2]. S told Q of instances how much he misses her and how he finds it impossible not to see her. She acceded and S claimed that she felt better at the end of the talk.

Later in the evening, I was walking back with S when he called up Q. Q, in a very stealthy way, asked him not to call or message him that night. S thinks that her boyfriend has given her a surprise visit and hence he obeyed her instructions. I asked him why he would not talk to her even when he wants to — "I don't want her to get into any trouble" was the simple reply.

His supportive behavior might sound impressive to some people, but it got me thinking and for once I saw why god must create those ugly edges along each of the beautiful packages. Traditionally people call it God's way of testing—I see those ugly edges as pointy corners that slice your wrists and make you bleed to near death to make sure that you have earned the package.

I don't hold any contempt against my good friend S but in my opinion, S has misread his feelings in a big way. He failed to stand up to his belief (that he loves Q and Q loves him). During this whole episode,

• He has tried to be supportive and loving, though actually at a subconscious level he conveyed his reluctance to act "like a man" and left Q in as much dilemma as she started with. He has expected Q to feel better of the situation without giving her any real reasons for it.
• He has successfully obscured her view of the situation that she has just started seeing in clear light. Hence her relief can only be very temporary.
• He chose to remain a silent spectator when C comes to Q's place in the evening; even though S was aware that Q might have to go through a very difficult time answering C. The very discussions that evening between C and Q can decide the future course of his proclaimed love.
• His arguments have failed to assure Q of his love and his commitment to make her happy without which Q, who is more inclined towards S, shall remain in an inextricable dilemma until she is able to perceive the real depths of S's feelings and realize her mistake in believing the thought process of a person who himself doesn't actually believe in those!!!

Such people as S usually play the game of being a victim. They fail to stand up to their "perceived" believes and they blame circumstances and others for their failure; gathering pity from others. Another observation of mine reveals a very sad fact that girls tend to feel more for such victims and their stories, without realizing that the stories are just about to be repeated because the director is the guy himself and he loves tragedy.

[1] Please note "until he returns to his country".
[2] Somehow he considered sexual activities as the only means of cheating on C.